How to Choose the Right Broadhead for Bow Hunting

How to Choose the Right Broadhead for Bow Hunting

Are you an avid bow hunter looking to enhance your hunting experience? Choosing the right broadhead plays a crucial role in ensuring a successful and humane hunt. With a wide range of options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to make the right choice. However, with the help of this comprehensive guide, you will learn the key factors to consider when selecting a broadhead for bow hunting. From understanding different types of broadheads to evaluating their features and performance, this article will provide you with all the essential information you need to make an informed decision. So, let’s dive in and explore the world of broadheads to take your bow hunting skills to the next level!

Considerations for Choosing a Broadhead

When it comes to bow hunting, selecting the right broadhead is crucial for a successful and ethical hunt. With various options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to determine which broadhead is best suited for your needs. To help you make an informed decision, here are some key considerations to keep in mind.

Type of Broadhead

The first consideration when choosing a broadhead is the type. There are primarily three types of broadheads available: fixed-blade, mechanical, and hybrid broadheads.

Fixed-blade Broadheads: These broadheads have stationary blades that are permanently fixed in position. They are known for their durability and reliability, making them a popular choice among traditional archers and bowhunters. Fixed-blade broadheads are known to provide superior penetration and are more suitable for larger game animals.

Mechanical Broadheads: Also known as expandable broadheads, these have blades that remain closed during flight but open upon impact. The expanding blades create larger wound channels, resulting in better blood trails. Mechanical broadheads are often preferred by hunters seeking long-range accuracy and high-velocity shots, as they offer improved aerodynamics.

Hybrid Broadheads: As the name suggests, hybrid broadheads combine characteristics of both fixed-blade and mechanical broadheads. They feature mechanical blades that are backed by a pair of fixed blades. This combination provides the benefits of both types, offering a balance between penetration, accuracy, and wound size.

Consider your specific hunting style, the game you plan to pursue, and your shooting preferences when choosing the type of broadhead that suits you best.


The weight of the broadhead plays a crucial role in its performance. Broadheads typically range from 75 to 125 grains, with some variations available outside this range.

Lightweight broadheads offer higher arrow speeds, flatter trajectories, and more extended range capabilities. They are ideal for hunters looking for long-range shots or those using lower draw weight bows. However, lightweight broadheads may sacrifice some penetration power.

On the other hand, heavier broadheads provide deeper penetration and are more suitable for larger game animals. They offer increased kinetic energy upon impact, resulting in better stopping power. Heavier broadheads are favored by hunters targeting animals like elk, moose, or bear.

Consider your bow’s draw weight, arrow speed, and the type of game you intend to hunt when selecting the appropriate weight for your broadhead.

Cutting Diameter

The cutting diameter refers to the width of the broadhead’s blades when fully open. It directly affects the size of the wound channel and the amount of tissue damage caused upon impact.

Broadheads with larger cutting diameters create wider wound channels, resulting in better blood trails and higher chances of a clean kill. They are particularly beneficial when hunting larger game animals or in situations where the shot placement might not be perfect.

However, broadheads with larger cutting diameters may sacrifice some penetration ability and may be less accurate at longer distances. Smaller cutting diameters offer better flight characteristics and deeper penetration but may result in narrower wound channels.

Consider the game you plan to hunt, the shot distances you anticipate, and the shot placement accuracy you are confident in when choosing the appropriate cutting diameter for your broadhead.

By considering the type of broadhead, weight, and cutting diameter, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your hunting needs and preferences. Remember, selecting the right broadhead is essential for maximizing your chances of a humane and successful bow hunting experience.

Fixed Blade Broadheads


Fixed blade broadheads have been a popular choice among bow hunters for many years. Their simplicity and reliability make them a preferred option for many hunting enthusiasts. Here are some advantages of using fixed blade broadheads:

  1. Accuracy: Fixed blade broadheads are known for their exceptional accuracy. Their design allows for a more consistent flight path and better stability, resulting in precise and predictable shot placement. This is especially crucial when aiming for vital organs of the prey.

  2. Penetration: The fixed blade design offers superior penetration compared to other types of broadheads. The sharp, sturdy blades cut through the target with ease, ensuring deep penetration and maximizing the chances of a quick and ethical kill. This is particularly advantageous when hunting larger game.

  3. Ease of Maintenance: Fixed blade broadheads are relatively easy to maintain. With their simple construction, they can be easily sharpened and reassembled, ensuring optimal performance throughout the hunting season. Additionally, there are no mechanical components that can malfunction or require regular adjustments.

  4. Toughness: Fixed blade broadheads are known for their durability and toughness. They can withstand high-impact shots and are less prone to damage when hitting hard surfaces like bones or trees. This robustness ensures that the broadhead remains functional even after encountering obstacles in the field.


While fixed blade broadheads offer numerous advantages, they also have a few drawbacks that hunters should consider:

  1. Flight Path Sensitivity: Fixed blade broadheads can be more sensitive to changes in the flight path compared to mechanical broadheads. Factors such as wind, arrow speed, and bow tuning can slightly alter the trajectory of the arrow, affecting accuracy. It is crucial to fine-tune your equipment and practice regularly to compensate for these variations.

  2. Noise and Wind Resistance: The fixed blade design creates more wind resistance during flight, which can result in reduced arrow speed and increased noise. This can make it challenging to maintain stealth and may alert the prey to your presence. Hunters using fixed blade broadheads need to be extra cautious and practice stealthy shooting techniques.

  3. Limited Cutting Diameter: Unlike some mechanical broadheads, fixed blade broadheads generally have a limited cutting diameter. This can potentially affect the wound channel and blood loss, especially when hunting larger game. However, with accurate shot placement, this disadvantage can be minimized.

  4. Potential for Injury: Due to their sharp and exposed blades, fixed blade broadheads pose a higher risk of injury during handling and transportation. It is essential to handle them with caution and use appropriate protective gear when working with these broadheads to avoid accidental cuts or punctures.

Despite these disadvantages, fixed blade broadheads remain a popular choice among bow hunters due to their proven track record, reliability, and overall performance in the field. Assess your hunting style, game preferences, and shooting skills to determine if fixed blade broadheads are the right choice for you.

Mechanical Broadheads


Mechanical broadheads have gained popularity among bow hunters for several reasons:

  1. Accuracy: Mechanical broadheads are known for their exceptional accuracy. Their streamlined design and precise engineering ensure consistent flight and precise shot placement, increasing the chances of a successful hunt.

  2. Higher Speed: These broadheads are typically lighter compared to fixed-blade broadheads, allowing them to achieve higher arrow speeds. The increased velocity translates to a flatter trajectory, making it easier to hit targets accurately over longer distances.

  3. Wider Cutting Diameter: One of the significant advantages of mechanical broadheads is their wider cutting diameter. Upon impact, the blades on a mechanical broadhead deploy, significantly increasing the size of the wound channel and enhancing the chances of a quick, humane kill. This feature is particularly advantageous when hunting larger game animals.

  4. Penetration: Mechanical broadheads offer excellent penetration due to their streamlined design and reduced surface area. The blades are often made from high-quality, sharp materials that can easily slice through animal tissue and vital organs, ensuring a swift and ethical kill.


While mechanical broadheads have numerous advantages, there are a few drawbacks to consider:

  1. Mechanical Failure: The primary concern with mechanical broadheads is the potential for mechanical failure. Since these broadheads rely on deploying blades upon impact, there is a small possibility that the blades may not fully open or fail to deploy at all. This can result in reduced cutting diameter, less effective penetration, and potentially a wounded animal.

  2. Complexity: Mechanical broadheads are more intricate in design compared to fixed-blade broadheads. With moving parts and deployment mechanisms, they are more prone to malfunction or damage during use. Additionally, these broadheads require regular maintenance to ensure proper functionality, including checking and replacing O-rings, springs, and blades.

  3. Cost: Mechanical broadheads tend to be more expensive than their fixed-blade counterparts. The advanced engineering and precise manufacturing processes involved in their production contribute to the higher price tag. This cost factor may be a deterrent for some hunters who are on a tight budget.

  4. Limited Reusability: Unlike some fixed-blade broadheads that can be resharpened and reused, most mechanical broadheads are designed for a single use. Once the blades are deployed and the broadhead strikes its target, the blades may become dull or damaged, making them unsuitable for additional shots. This can make hunting with mechanical broadheads a more expensive endeavor in the long run.

Despite these disadvantages, many bow hunters still opt for mechanical broadheads due to their undeniable advantages in terms of accuracy, cutting diameter, and overall performance. It is important for hunters to weigh these pros and cons and choose the broadhead type that aligns with their hunting style, target game, and personal preferences.

Hybrid Broadheads


  • Versatility: Hybrid broadheads combine the best features of both fixed blade and mechanical broadheads. They offer the accuracy of fixed blade broadheads and the larger cutting diameter of mechanical broadheads. This versatility allows hunters to adapt to different hunting situations and game sizes.

  • Increased accuracy: Hybrid broadheads are known for their exceptional accuracy. With their fixed blades, they provide better flight stability and consistency, resulting in improved precision when shooting. This accuracy is crucial for bow hunters aiming for vital organs to ensure a clean and ethical kill.

  • Wider cutting diameter: One of the major advantages of hybrid broadheads is their wider cutting diameter. Unlike fixed blade broadheads, hybrids have expandable blades that open upon impact, creating a larger wound channel. This increased cutting diameter enhances the chances of hitting vital organs and improves the efficiency of the shot.

  • Penetration power: Hybrid broadheads are designed to penetrate the target effectively. The combination of fixed blades and mechanical components allows for deep penetration, ensuring the broadhead reaches vital organs for a quick and humane kill. This is particularly advantageous when hunting larger game that requires more force to penetrate their tough hide and muscle.


  • Complexity: Hybrid broadheads tend to be more complex in design compared to fixed blade or mechanical broadheads. The combination of both types of blades requires careful assembly and maintenance. In some cases, the mechanical components may malfunction, affecting the broadhead’s performance. Hunters using hybrid broadheads should be prepared to invest time in learning how to properly assemble and maintain them.

  • Cost: Hybrid broadheads are generally more expensive than fixed blade or mechanical broadheads. The combination of features and materials increases their manufacturing cost, which is reflected in their price. For hunters on a tight budget, the higher cost of hybrid broadheads may be a limiting factor.

  • Durability: With the inclusion of mechanical components, hybrid broadheads may be more prone to damage or failure. The moving parts can be susceptible to wear and tear, reducing their overall durability. Hunters must ensure regular inspection and replacement of any damaged parts to maintain the broadhead’s performance.

  • Limited selection: Compared to fixed blade and mechanical broadheads, the selection of hybrid broadheads available on the market may be somewhat limited. While the variety has been increasing over the years, it may still be challenging for hunters to find a specific style or brand that suits their preferences. This limited selection can sometimes make it difficult to find the ideal hybrid broadhead for a particular hunting situation.

Remember, when choosing the right broadhead for bow hunting, it is important to consider the advantages and disadvantages of each type, including hybrid broadheads. Assess your hunting needs, preferences, and budget to make an informed decision that aligns with your hunting goals.

Considerations for Bow Hunting Game

Game Species

When it comes to bow hunting, it is essential to consider the specific game species you will be targeting. Different animals have different anatomies, which can affect the type of broadhead you should choose. For instance, broadheads designed for larger game like elk or moose may have different features compared to those used for smaller game such as deer or turkey. Understanding the game species you will be hunting will help you select the right broadhead that can effectively penetrate and deliver a humane kill.

Shot Placement

Shot placement is crucial for a successful bow hunt, and it also impacts the type of broadhead you should select. Depending on the shot placement you prefer, certain broadheads may be more suitable than others. For example, if you aim for a lung shot, a broadhead with a wide cutting diameter and sharp blades may be ideal to maximize blood loss and ensure a quick, ethical kill. On the other hand, if you prefer a heart shot, a broadhead with deep penetration capabilities may be more important. Understanding your preferred shot placement and considering the broadhead’s design can greatly enhance your hunting success.

Bow Speed

The speed at which your bow shoots arrows is another important factor to consider when choosing the right broadhead. Different broadheads are designed to perform optimally at specific bow speeds. For instance, mechanical broadheads are typically more suitable for faster bows, as they rely on the arrow’s momentum to open up upon impact. On the other hand, fixed-blade broadheads may be better suited for slower bows, as they are generally more durable and dependable. By understanding the speed capabilities of your bow and selecting a broadhead that matches it, you can ensure optimal performance and accuracy during your hunts.

Consider these crucial factors when choosing the right broadhead for your bow hunting adventures. By understanding the game species you will be pursuing, the desired shot placement, and the speed of your bow, you can make an informed decision that will enhance your hunting experience and increase your chances of a successful harvest.

Broadhead Maintenance and Durability

When it comes to bow hunting, choosing the right broadhead is crucial for a successful and ethical hunt. However, it is equally important to properly maintain and ensure the durability of your broadheads. This section will cover some important aspects of broadhead maintenance and durability, including sharpening, replacement blades, and overall durability.


Keeping your broadheads sharp is essential for accurate and effective shots. Over time, broadheads can become dull due to repeated use or hitting hard surfaces. To maintain their sharpness, regular sharpening is necessary. Here are some steps to follow when sharpening your broadheads:

  1. Inspect the blades: Before sharpening, inspect the blades for any damage or nicks. If there are any visible issues, it is recommended to replace the blades entirely.

  2. Use a sharpening stone: Secure the broadhead in a vice or use a sharpening stone holder to hold it steady. Using a sharpening stone, gently and evenly run it along the edge of the blades. Maintain a consistent angle and apply light pressure. Repeat this process until the blades are sharp.

  3. Test the sharpness: After sharpening, carefully touch the edge of the blades to check their sharpness. Be cautious to avoid any accidental cuts. If the blades are not sharp enough, repeat the sharpening process until desired results are achieved.

Replacement Blades

Over time, broadhead blades can become worn out or damaged. In such cases, it is important to replace them to maintain optimal performance. Replacement blades are available for most broadhead models and are relatively easy to install. Here are the general steps to follow when replacing broadhead blades:

  1. Remove the old blades: Carefully unscrew or remove the old blades from the broadhead. Pay attention to any washers or additional components that may be present during the removal process.

  2. Clean the broadhead: Before installing new blades, clean the broadhead thoroughly to remove any debris or residue. This will ensure a proper fit for the replacement blades.

  3. Install the new blades: Following the manufacturer’s instructions, align the replacement blades with the broadhead and secure them in place. Use the necessary screws or locking mechanisms to ensure a tight fit.

  4. Test the replacement blades: After installation, test the replacement blades by gently tapping them to ensure they are securely attached. Additionally, check their alignment to ensure they are straight and properly aligned with the ferrule.


Durability is an essential factor when choosing a broadhead for bow hunting. A durable broadhead will withstand the impact of hitting the target and potentially hitting hard surfaces like bones. Consider the following aspects when evaluating the durability of a broadhead:

  1. Construction materials: Broadheads made from high-quality materials like stainless steel or titanium tend to be more durable. These materials offer excellent strength and resistance to corrosion.

  2. Design features: Look for broadheads with reinforced ferrules or blades that are known for their durability. Some broadheads come with added features like blade locking systems or replaceable blades, which can enhance their overall durability.

  3. User reviews: Researching user reviews and feedback can provide valuable insights into the durability of specific broadhead models. Look for reviews from experienced hunters who have extensively tested the broadheads in real hunting situations.

By properly maintaining your broadheads through sharpening, replacing blades when needed, and considering their overall durability, you can ensure that your hunting equipment remains in optimal condition. This will contribute to accurate shots, ethical hunting practices, and a successful bow hunting experience.

In conclusion, choosing the right broadhead for bow hunting is crucial for ensuring a successful and ethical hunt. It is important to consider factors such as the type of game being hunted, the desired shooting distance, and personal shooting style. By understanding the different types of broadheads available and their respective advantages and disadvantages, hunters can make an informed decision that best suits their needs. Additionally, regular practice and familiarity with the chosen broadhead are essential for accuracy and consistency during hunts. With proper research and consideration, hunters can equip themselves with the right broadhead to maximize their hunting experience.